As a seasoned Chief Financial Officer, I am always weary of the “costs” people save that never show up. Sometimes they are malarkey and often they are mistakes. However, when a seasoned continuous improvement professional approaches me about measured savings, I tend to trust their analysis. Where I need to push them on is how their efficiencies translate into an observable financial outcome. In the famous words of the old Wendy’s commercial: “Where’s the Beef?”
Understanding Hard/Type I and Soft/Type II Savings
Suppose a Lean Six Sigma project reduces annual scrap from $2 million to $1.5 million.
Assuming production volume and other relevant factors haven't changed materially, a $500,000 cost reduction should show up on the P&L. This is what we call a “hard savings” or a Type I benefit: a direct financial impact. CFOs love these types of savings. They’re visible, quantifiable and have a direct impact on financial performance. Other examples of these types of hard savings are lower raw-material consumption, reduced overtime, lower freight expense, reduced warranty expense and overall lower manufacturing costs.
On the other hand, CFOs are much less comfortable with Type II benefits or “soft” savings: avoided costs or economic benefit that has not yet resulted in an observable P&L change.
Suppose a Lean Six Sigma project reduces 100 employee hours every month.
As a grouchy CFO, I may ask: “So what? Are people now leaving early on Fridays?”
Jokes aside, it’s not that productivity gains don’t matter. It’s a question of what those productivity gains lead to.
See how much time and money Minitab Engage could save your continuous improvement program.
Where Continuous Improvement Programs Go Wrong: Taking Credit for Hard Savings That Are Really Soft
Imagine that a continuous improvement project automates a process and reduces the work of an employee manually compiling reports to five hours a week from 30 hours per week. That’s a 25-hour savings per week and 1,300 hours saved in a year. If the employee’s labor cost is $50 per hour, then that’s $65,000 of annual labor capacity created. However, it is not $65,000 in savings.
In an effort to attribute value to their projects, many continuous improvement programs will call the $65,000 “savings,” which frankly undermines the credibility of the CI program.
Calling it worthless would be equally ridiculous too. The question is: what happens to those 1,300 hours? Because if those 1,300 are leading to summer Fridays, your CFO may not care.
What CI Programs Need to Do: Follow Their Type II Savings Until They Become Type I
The most credible approach begins without dollars. In the above example, the project created 1,300 hours of labor capacity. That’s objectively measurable and the potential economic value could be substantial. The problem is that the company hasn’t earned it yet.
Now, imagine that those 1,300 hours of savings allowed an operator to work one more shift per month. Now, those 1,300 hours are production hours.
If each production hour produces, $300 of contribution margin, all of a sudden, those 1,300 hours are worth $390,000 of measurable margin contribution.
Patience is a Virtue When It Comes to Type II Savings
When it comes to Type II savings, many continuous improvement programs stop too early.
They document the saving. Celebrate the project. Close it and move on.
Instead, keep asking what gains are coming from the efficiencies created? There are typically several possibilities. The gains enabled your company to produce more, avoid hiring, limit overtime or lower capital expenditures. Once those gains can be converted and captured, they become Type I hard savings.
When you show your finance department real, hard savings, not only will you get more support, but also more investments in things like software and headcount to expand your program. And if you’re lucky, and you can convince your grouchy CFO of hard savings, maybe, just maybe, he or she may even let you go home early on a Friday.
Want to see how Type II soft savings become measurable financial results? Join our upcoming webinar for the full discussion, including practical tips for choosing projects that deliver Type I savings.