How to Predict and Prevent Product Failure

Minitab Guest Blogger | 30 October, 2020

Topics: Automotive, Manufacturing, Continuous Improvement, Predictive Analytics, Minitab Statistical Software, Reliability Analysis

Imagine your new car breaks down after driving 60 miles. The engine light turns on and your vehicle must now be towed to be serviced. This is not only a warranty issue but also a field problem due to lack of product reliability.

Reliability is defined as the quality of a product over time and statistically speaking it is the probability of a product not to fail during a defined period of time.

This article was co-written with Mr. Serhan Anac, a Certified Six Sigma Black Belt and Shainin RedX Master. Serhan Anac is a problem solving expert with 11 years of experience at Robert Bosch in Turkey.

Leading Customer Quality projects, Serhan is also involved in Research and Development, hence his interest in Reliability as well as Monte Carlo Simulation and more analytical engineering methods.

A statistics, data science and Minitab enthusiast, Serhan helps his organisation to improve processes and find solutions to daily manufacturing problems, so is happy to share his best practices to help other Quality Professionals learn and grow in their careers.

The Risk Of Failure

In cases like this one, the original equipment manufacturers (OEM) would be at fault. These OEMS must then quickly find the root cause and determine the risk for other vehicles still operating in field so they can predict how many additional vehicles will return with the same problem or continue driving with no problems at all (also called survivors). Eventually if the risk is high enough, a vehicle recall in that market could be necessary.

Once the part that has failed has been found, you would determine the outstanding risk* and begin calculating the probability for a given time period. Generally, life data (e.g. cycles, mileage, operating time) does not often fit the normal distribution, so the Weibull distribution model model is recommended to perform the reliability analysis to make predictions using Minitab Statistical Software.

Related Blog: Why Quantifying Failure and Survival Risk Matter

Reliability and Survival The High Stakes of Product Performance

To perform the reliability analysis in Minitab Statistical Software, the following data is required:

  • Failure quantity

  • Mileage at failure

  • Failure date

  • Production date of failed parts

  • Vehicle registration date

  • Volume produced during the period at stake

With the data above, we can provide the required inputs for the analysis using Minitab Statistical Software.

A Closer Look at the Data

42 vehicles failed in field due to a malfunction of the fuel injection equipment. These were reported by Original Equipment Manufacturers. The number is low compared to 11.9 million parts produced because early failures, namely infant mortality, were also recorded.

Even though some parts have failed, survivors still operate in field. We need consider the quantity of survivors and their mileage to date.

Running the Reliability Analysis

A Parametric Distribution Analysis will help us to calculate how many vehicles are likely to fail.

Probability Plot for Mileage_Minitab Statistical Software

Graph: Weibull Probability Plot


Looking to learn more on reliability analysis? Attend any of our Minitab Training courses offered worldwide: Read the course description and enquire now!


How Many Vehicles Are Likely to Fail?

Vehicles drive in average approximately 45000 kilometers a year. The estimated cumulative probability until 45000 kilometers and until 135000 kilometers are reported in the table displayed below.

Table: Cumulative Failure Probabilities

11.9 million parts were produced. The 95% Confidence level upper bound estimates the maximum expected return failure of 0.0000037. As a consequence, out of 1 million parts we can expect 3.7 failures.

Out of 11.9 million vehicles, 44 vehicles are likely to fail:

11.9 million parts x 3.7 parts per million = 44 parts likely to fail

42 vehicles have already failed, 2 are expected as potential returns below 45000 km.

Original Equipment Manufacturers have usually signed a warranty agreement with component suppliers: parts must not fail under a set period of time.

This data-driven approach is useful .

Minitab Statistical Software offers a wide range of functionality for calculating the reliability of product, some of which were demonstrated in this example.

* Note: Risk is determined both qualitatively and quantitatively, but we have focused on the quantitative aspect only in this blog.

Case study:
Time-to-Market and Design for Reliability at the Speed of Light in Signify

Get ready for a light bulb moment! In a fast-changing industry where time-to-market and product reliability give a competitive edge, discover how the world’s leading lighting company Signify, rapidly validates new innovations. In this one hour case study webinar, Prof W.D. van Driel and Dr P. Watté will shed a light on design for reliability (DfR) using Minitab Statistical Software at Signify, the former Philips Lighting. Learn from real-life examples their methods to lower your development costs, improve your designs’ performance and compliance, and accelerate the testing of product design reliability. If you develop products intended to meet high specifications for years to come, you will discover how to reduce the risks and consequences of product failure and costly claims - for you and your customers. Replay the webinar in your own time >

Watch Now Webinar On-Demand

New call-to-action